Framework: Section 2C -
'Last days'? eschaton (part 1), Gospels (part 1)

2C) 'Last days'? The censer, beginning of the eschaton and the Gospels

This study uses the word ‘eschaton’,  rather than the ‘last days’ or ‘end times’, to represent the time surrounding the revealing of Christ (the Parousia, or his ‘coming’, in Revelation), i.e. when Jesus will be seen again on earth.  This is a deliberate choice because the Greek word eschaton signifies ‘last’ (or utmost, or extreme), without stressing a chronological climax, the end of history[1] or cessation of time.  The concept implies there are the first days (or a beginning), perhaps Creation itself (4:11, 12:5).  Those days are recorded in 4:2-5:4 in heaven’s throne-room, and in 12:1-8 and 12:13-16 in heaven’s environs or on a mythic or pre-history earth that reflects the narrative in the Hebrew Bible (Framework 1).

 

After the Cross (the death, resurrection and ascension of Jesus; 5:5-6:1, 12:9-12, 12:17-18; time-parallel 1; Framework 1), are John’s ‘present age’ or the ‘times of the gentiles’, in which Jerusalem will be downtrodden (Lk. 21:24).  The start of these times is not defined because Judea was occupied before the Cross, and they end when the times are ‘fulfilled’, i.e. when Christ is revealed.  In Revelation these days are recorded in 6:2-11:19 (the seals, censer and trumpets) and 12:17-18.  This study proposes that when the heavenly silence ends and the golden censer is thrown to earth (8:2), the eschaton begins – and the trumpets are the harbingers of the Parousia (Frameworks 3, 4 and 5).  There are libraries full of books and articles written about the eschaton and the Parousia but this study is limited to considering what the proposed spatio-temporal analysis may add to the narrative.

 

[1] John’s relationship to history and the surrounding culture is ambiguous.  ‘History’ is used in a modern sense here; how Jews in the first century A.D. understood history is uncertain but Halbwachs distinguished it from collective memory, which is how the first Christians outside Palestine would have remembered Jerusalem and the temple and its traditions (rituals etc.), Halbwachs, 1992: 222).

2C.a) The golden censer and trumpets begin

After the Silence ends, seven angels are given trumpets (8:2) and the golden censer is prepared by another angel (8:3-5a).  The golden censer is hurled to earth, and earth responds with storms and an earthquake (8:5b); it is as if the earth is anointed by the fire and sacrifice from the altar, perhaps preparing it for the torments which follow.  This is perhaps an allusion to part of the ceremony Aaron performed on the Day of Atonement, in which the smoke from the censer is a protection for Aaron when the sacrifices for his sins and the sins of the people were presented on the altar (Lev.16:12-13).  This is also a cleansing process; Isaiah has a vision of God seated on a throne and Isaiah recognises his own need for cleansing when the heavenly temple shakes and fills with smoke (Is. 6:1-13).[1]  An angelic being responds to Isaiah’s lament of unworthiness by taking a burning coal from the altar and touching his (Isaiah’s) mouth with it so that his guilt and sin may be atoned for.  The need for protection of the faithful and Israel’s purification within Isaiah’s vision is similar to the needs of corrupt society described in Revelation.[2]  In both situations the tool of God’s punishment for sin is invasion by foreign armies.  In Isaiah, after the invasion (Is. 5:26-30), the nation will continue (a tenth of the people will be preserved, Is. 6:13).  In Revelation, the invasion is the gathering armies of the kings from the east (16:12-16) before the earthquake destroys Babylon (16:17-21) and she is ruined by the beast (17:16, Framework 4).  The invasions may pre-figure (as in Isaiah’s time) or be part of the Day of God’s Wrath (as in Revelation; see Framework 3 to 5) but both these events follow a cleansing and protection process.

 

Grant Osborne refers to ‘the purifying effect of suffering’ (Osborne, 2002: 209) and the message to Laodicea refers to ‘gold refined by fire (…) I reprove and discipline those whom I love.’ (3:18-19) but Osborne also suggest the emptying of the censer represents judgement thrown to earth (Osborne, 2002: 346-347).  This study suggests the storm and earthquake (8:5b) is more representative of the power of God, and his ability to purify and protect, than his judgement.  The emptying of the censer may be a cleansing/ protecting process which represents resumption of activity on earth after the long heavenly silence and it may be the first event in the eschaton.

 

The angels were given the trumpets before the censer was filled (8:2), and they now prepare to sound them (8:6).  Trumpet blasts are traditionally associated with warnings; the first four are in this section and the final three announce the three woes (Framework 3).  The blasts themselves are not the torments but they are accompanied by torments hurled down to/ or darkness on earth (8:7-12).

 

John’s role as a prophet is to convict people of their sin and to encourage repentance, and the Church’s role is to bear witness to the Gospel, before the great Day of God’s Wrath arrives (Jauhiainen, 2003a: 552).  The plea to repent is part of five of the seven messages to the churches (2:1-3:22, Framework 1).  Refusal to repent is a feature of the second woe (sixth trumpet, 9:20-21) and third woe (fourth and fifth bowl, 16:9-11); this assumes the bowls are the anticipated third woe of the seventh trumpet (11:14-15, Framework 3).  The last opportunity to repent before the harvests is during the seventh bowl (18:4, Framework 4).  This suggests the trumpets’ purpose is to warn of coming judgement and the purpose of the woes (including the bowls full of the wrath of God that are carried by the seven plague angels, 15:1-16:21) is to actively encourage repentance.

 

It is proposed in this section that the censer torments may represent the beginning of the eschaton (‘last days’) and the trumpets warn of the imminent Parousia (the coming of Christ).  There has already been nearly 2000 years since Jerusalem fell and the hiatus of the seventh seal silence is part of the ‘times of the Gentiles’ (Lk. 21:24).  The timescales for future events is unknown and how humanity would be able to tell the difference between the different series of torments is uncertain. 

 

[1] People faithful to God are part of society but affluence breeds corruption and sin.  Israel must follow Isaiah’s example of confession of sin and cleansing to avoid God’s judgement (Webb, 1996: 58).

[2] Corrupt Babylon: 14:8, 17:5, 18:2-5, 19:2.  ‘Come out of her (Babylon), my people, so that you do not take part in her sins, and so that you do not share in her plagues’, 18:4.

2C.b) The Gospels and Revelation: post-Cross times ('the present age')

Interpretation of this part of the proposed spatio-temporal macrostructure is guided and validated by the Gospels, particularly Lk. 17 and Lk. 21/ Mt. 24-25/ Mk. 13, aided by a synopsis of the four Gospels (Aland, 1985).  Gospel warnings relate to both the immediate post-Cross era and warnings of events surrounding the Parousia.  In John’s day, these times were called ‘the present age’ and ‘the age to come’ (Wright, 2011: 220).  The Gospels record how Jesus laments the anticipated fall of Jerusalem and pleads for people to avoid the catastrophe:[1] when believers see armies surround Jerusalem (Lk. 21:20), flee to the hills because its inhabitants will be killed or taken captive (Lk. 21:21-24).  Matthew and Mark add: flee when the desolating sacrilege is set up (in the Jerusalem Temple is implied, Mt. 24:15-22, Mk. 13:14-20).  Luke warns that the besieging armies will take captives, so flee!  According to Eusebius Pamphilius,[2]  Christians ‘commanded by a revelation’ heeded warnings to flee Jerusalem before the Jewish wars (A.D. 66-70) and they escaped to Pella (Ecclesiastical History 3.5.3).  In Revelation, this may correspond to the destructive earthquake and cosmic manifestations associated with the sixth seal (6:12-17; Framework 2B.a).  The destruction is so catastrophic that even generals and kings think the Day of God’s Wrath has come.  Instead of facing the Wrath, the 144,000 faithful are sealed and four angels bind the four winds at the four corners of the earth (7:1-8), so the devastation they will bring is delayed until later.

 

Mt. 24:3-14, Mk. 13:3-13 and Lk. 21:7-19 warn there will be both current and future tribulations.  Jerusalem will be downtrodden ‘until the times of the gentiles are fulfilled’ (Lk. 21:24).  Matthew and Mark add: the tribulation will be shortened (Mt. 24:22, Mk. 13:20) but do not pause to look for the Son of Man because these things will happen before he appears (Mt. 24:23-27, Mk. 13:21-23) and where the body (πτῶμα) is, there the eagles or vultures (ἀετοι) will be gathered together (Mt. 24:28).  Matthew’s word for ‘body’ indicates it could be dead (a corpse) and this suggests anticipation of the crucifixion. The metaphor may allude to ἀετοὶ as eagles (armies) gathering around the crucified Christ (every Roman Legion had an Eagle Standard, D’Amato, 2018: 9).  Luke uses the same phrase but with an important modification (‘where the body (σῶμα) is, there the eagles or vultures (ἀετοι) will be gathered together’, Lk. 17:37) but the body could be living so the metaphor may allude to ἀετοι as eagles (armies) gathering when the living Christ is revealed (at the Parousia; this will be considered again in Framework 5C).  The parables which follow these discourses reinforce the need for steadfastness, humility and watchfulness[3] in anticipation of the coming of the Son of Man in glory, and final judgement of the nations.[4]

 

The Gospels warned the first generations after the Cross about what will happen and Revelation puts the events into a Creation – New Order context.  The interpretation of the seals in this study implies that at least some of the events traditionally associated the eschaton (the seals) began at the Cross.  Depending upon when Revelation was first circulated, some of the readers/ listeners may have recognised in Rome’s actions and the fall of Jerusalem (A.D. 70) the tribulations described in the vision, i.e. persecution (the martyrs of the fifth seal) and Jerusalem’s fall (sixth seal) – and they were able to flee the destruction.  The seal torments are both physical (conquest, war, famine and death) and spiritual (the influence of the four horsemen of the first four seals; 6:2-8).  The seals affect the same dimension that John, the Warrior and the congregations/ lamp-stands occupy (1:10-4:1), i.e. a direct continuation of events from the Cross on the visionary physical-spiritual earth.  Meanwhile, Satan ‘stands by the sea’ on the biblical earth throughout this period, and this malign influence results in ongoing war with God’s faithful people (12:17-18; see Framework 1B.e).

 

[1] Steadfastness/humility: Lk. 18:1-14, watchfulness Lk. 19:11-27, Mt. 24:45-25:30, Mk. 13:33-37.

[2] Mt 25:31-46, see also Lk. 12:35-46, Lk. 19:11-27 and Mt. 16:27, Mk. 8:38b, Lk. 9:26b.

[3] Fall of Jerusalem: Mt. 23:37-39; Lk. 13:34-35, 19:41-44.

[4] In his Ecclesiastical History, Eusebius Pamphilus (A.D. c.301-c.400), Bishop of Caesarea, used an extensive library of early Christian writings to record and comment on the history of the Church from the end of the Book of Acts to the time of Emperor Constantine.  Most of the original texts no longer exist.

2C.c) The Gospels and Revelation: pre-Parousia times ('the age to come' begins)

In the Gospels, there is a hiatus between the ascension of Jesus and the time immediately leading up to the Parousia, which (in Revelation) may include the silence of the seventh seal in heaven (8:1, Framework 2).  Jerusalem will be downtrodden ‘until the times of the gentiles are fulfilled’ (Lk. 21:24).  Matthew and Mark add: the tribulation will be shortened (Mt. 24:22, Mk. 13:20) but do not pause to look for the Son of Man because these things will happen before he appears (Mt. 24:23-27, Mk. 13:21-23).

 

     ‘You will hear of wars and rumours of wars, but see to it that you are not alarmed. Such things must happen, but the end is still to come.  Nation will rise against nation, and kingdom against kingdom. There will be famines and earthquakes in various places.  All these are the beginning of birth pains.  Then you will be handed over to be persecuted and put to death, and you will be hated by all nations because of me.  At that time many will turn away from the faith and will betray and hate each other, and many false prophets will appear and deceive many people.  Because of the increase of wickedness, the love of most will grow cold, but the one who stands firm to the end will be saved.  And this gospel of the kingdom will be preached in the whole world as a testimony to all nations, and then the end will come.’ (Mt. 24:6-14, see also Mk: 13:7-13, Lk. 21:9-19).

 

This is a period in which people are living ordinary lives (despite wars, famines and earthquakes), like in the times of Noah (Lk. 17:26-27, Mt. 24:37-39) or Lot (Lk. 17:28-33).  There will be temptations for hedonism, like a sudden snare (Lk. 21:34); take heed, watch! (Lk. 21:34-36).  The need for the faithful to prepare and watch is emphasised by parables (Mt. 24:45-25:30, Mk. 13:33-37).  Believers must be aware, ‘this generation’ will witnesses these events (Lk. 21:29-33, Mt.24:32-36, Mk. 13:28-32) so be watchful and prepared for Christ will appear at an unknown hour (Mt. 24:36, Mk.13:32).  The generation referred to may be the stubbornly resistant of any era (Green, 1997: 742), but these are words of prophecy particularly for those who were alive when Jesus was on earth and for those who will witness the Parousia.  The first generation saw the trauma that will be like the ‘birth-pangs’ of the end of the age (Mt. 24:3-8, Mk. 13:3-8) and the second may be overwhelmed by hedonism.  Christ could appear at any time so be aware, watchful and prepared.

 

In Revelation, this middle or in-between time (post-Cross/ pre-Parousia) includes the silence of the seventh seal (8:1), because the Silence represents a clear separation between the seals and the trumpets.  It is an hiatus in heaven and on earth, before the censer empties and the eschaton (‘last days’ or ‘end times’) begin.  Meanwhile, on the biblical earth, war on earth continues and satan continues to stand by the sea (12:17-18; Figure 1 and Framework 1), still waiting for his beasts to arise (13:1) (Figure 3, Framework 3).  The hedonism described in the Gospels that is rampant when Christ appears, is fully realised in Babylon.  Babylon is the great city and harlot who illustrates how society is dominated by the corrupt lifestyles of those who do not reject their evil ways (14:8, 16:17-21, 17:1-18:24); her downfall is recorded in Framework 4.  Christ could appear at any time so be aware, watchful and prepared (16:15).

2C.d) Seals, trumpets and bowls in John’s ‘present age’ and ‘the age to come’

One of the disturbing aspects of Revelation is the repetitive catastrophes of the seals, trumpets and bowls (the septets) which begin and never end – until the very end.  By putting these into the Creation – New Order context in the proposed macrostructure their presence is explained as cycles of disasters that cover 2000 years (to date).  Details of the septets are considered in the Construction sections of Frameworks 1 to 4.  The first disasters began in John’s ‘present age’, at the Cross when the slain Lamb takes the scroll from the right hand of the One-seated-on-the-throne (5:7) and he opens its seven seals (see Framework 1).  Grant Osborne suggests there is a transfer of authority to the Lamb with the scroll (Osborne, 2002:257) and this is confirmed by 12:10-11:

 

     ‘Then I heard a loud voice in heaven, proclaiming, ‘Now have come the salvation and the power and the kingdom of our God and the authority of his Messiah, for the accuser of our comrades has been thrown down, who accuses them day and night before our God.  But they have conquered him by the blood of the Lamb and by the word of their testimony, for they did not cling to life even in the face of death’.

 

This is illustrated in time-parallel 1 (Framework 1).  When the Lamb opens the first four seals, four horsemen are released – bringing with them conquest, civil war, social unrest and famine, plague and wild beasts invading decimated communities (6:2-8).  Such outrages occurred before the Cross but they intensified afterwards, with the expansion and control by the Roman Empire: persecution of the faithful as witnessed by the martyrs rejoicing (fifth seal, 6:9-11) and the catastrophic earthquake (sixth seal, 6:12-21) perhaps represents the besiege and fall of Jerusalem in 70 A.D.  Four angels held back the four winds at the four corners of the earth until the 144,000 servants of God from all the tribes of Israel were sealed (7:1-8), so the trauma was somewhat mitigated at that time.  The impact of the four horsemen is endless; conquest, war, famine and death continue today.  This study proposes that John saw visionary events on earth in their true form – as an inter-twining of the spiritual (the horsemen) and the physical (the resulting torments).  In John’s day, a sealed contract was usually opened when it was ready to be implemented and by opening the seals the Lamb initiated the new era of messianic authority.  The counterpart of 4:1-8:12 is 12:1-18 in the proposed macrostructure, and Richard Bauckham calls 12:1-14:20 the ‘messianic war’ (Bauckham, 1993a: 94).  The Cross did not create the seal torments, the seals are part of that war.

 

After the hiatus of the Silence of the seventh seal (8:1) and the ‘times of the Gentiles’ (Lk. 21:24), i.e. 2000 years later (to date), the Censer is thrown to earth and ‘the age to come’ (the eschaton) begins and the trumpets sound (8:7-11:19).  They affect the same physical-spiritual space as the seals, and the first four trumpets follow a similar pattern: burning land, sea contamination and a third of the sea creatures and ships are destroyed, contaminated fresh water and there is darkness; and the spiritual elements are the trumpet blasts themselves, and perhaps the combustion welling up from within the horses, like the smoke which rose when the abyss opened (9:2).  Two ‘woes’ follow on the physical-spiritual earth, when the abyss and earth open (9:1-21, fifth and sixth trumpets) and satan’s beasts appear on the biblical earth (13:1-18) (Framework 3, time-parallels 2 and 3).  A lot happens when the sixth trumpet sounds, during the second woe: four angels are released at the Euphrates, John meets the ‘mighty angel’, he hears the seven thunders’ message, he measures the Temple, he sees the ‘two witnesses’ (10:1-11:14) and when the seventh trumpet sounds, John sees the heavenly sanctuary open (11:15-19).  Trumpets traditionally sound warnings so it is likely that the seven blasts warn of imminent disasters – but they do not create them.  In other words, they may herald imminent judgement but they are warnings designed to give people time to act.  In Revelation, the action required is repentance, but some people continue to worship demons and idols and they do not repent of their evil ways (9:20-21).  The focus of the idolatry is on the recently installed, speaking image of the abyss beast (13:14-15) and they see fire as a sign from heaven endorsing the authority of the earth beast (13:13).

 

If the trumpet blasts are warnings of imminent judgement, the seventh trumpet may stop sounding when the Lamb appears on Mt Zion (14:1-5) because his appearance on the biblical earth immediately follows the blast on the physical-spiritual earth (Frameworks 3 and 4).  The proposed macrostructure indicates that the sign of the seven plague (bowl) angels appears (15:1) when the ‘two witnesses’ are appointed and killed in Jerusalem, during the time of the sixth trumpet (11:3-10; time-parallel 5).  The angels are given golden bowls full of the wrath of God (15:6-8) and the torments associated with the first four bowls are similar in nature to the equivalent seals and trumpets: sores, contaminated water, cosmic disturbances and scorched earth (16:2-9).  This is the beginning of the long anticipated Day of God’s Wrath (since 6:12, and in the Hebrew Bible).[1]   In the Gospels, this period is like the times of Noah (Lk. 17:26-27, Mt. 24:37-39) or Lot (Lk. 17:28-33) (see 2C.c).  The bowls are the ‘third woe’ that was anticipated before the seventh trumpet sounded (11:14).

 

Timescales for the septets are very different. The first six seals may have ended in 70 A.D. but the seventh seal continues for 2,000 years (to date).  How long the first four trumpets will sound is unknown but, if the interpretation in this study is correct, satan’s abyss beast appears on the biblical earth during the fifth trumpet (time-parallel 2, Framework 3) and his operational time is very short (13:5).  After the seventh trumpet sounds, the bowls empty very quickly and when the fifth bowl empties people are still suffering from the pains and sores from the first four bowls (16:9-11).  During the sixth bowl, armies gather (17:17-19) and during the seventh bowl Babylon falls in an hour (18:10, 18:17-19; time-parallel 10) and she is ruined by plagues, famine and fire in a single day (18:8), i.e. a very short time.  Satan’s beasts are defeated in the Great Battle, which is the climax of the Day of God’s Wrath (19:20-21; time-parallel 15, Framework 5).  This is consistent with the Gospels’ reference to ‘one generation’ witnessing events (Lk. 21:32, Mt. 24:34, Mk. 13:30), i.e. a single generation witnessed events at the inception of the kingdom of God, and another single generation will witness the Parousia and see its fulfilment.

 

[1] For example, Zech. 14:1-5: ‘See, a day is coming for the Lord (…) For I will gather all the nations against Jerusalem to battle, (…destruction, exile …) Then the Lord will go forth and fight against those nations (…) On that day his feet shall stand on the Mount of Olives (… earthquake …). Then the Lord my God will come, and all the holy ones with him.’

2C) Summary and conclusions

This study compares Revelation with Lk. 17 and Lk. 21/ Mt. 24-25/ Mk. 13.  Jesus’ words recorded in Mt. 24:28, referring to the ‘body’ (πτῶμα) and eagles or vultures (ἀετοι) gathering, may be a reference to the crucifixion itself; this is time-parallel 1 in the proposed macrostructure.  There is a change in authority from satan to Jesus Christ at this time and satan was at war with the children of the ‘celestial mother’ and this war now includes the followers of Christ (12:17).  In this section, this study proposes that Jesus’ recorded prediction of the Jerusalem Temple’s destruction and ‘the great tribulation’ (Lk. 21:5-24a, Mt. 24:1-22, Mk. 13:1-20) correspond to the torments of the first six seals (6:2-17).  Persecutions of the faithful are represented by the martyrs of the fifth seal (6:9-11) and the victims of the ‘great tribulation’ (7:13-17).  The fall of Jerusalem may correspond to the sixth seal because everyone thinks the great earthquake and cosmic signs indicate that the Day of God’s Wrath is upon them – but it is not; this catastrophic event is part of John’s ‘present age’.  The four angels at the four corners of the earth are told to wait and the 144,000 representatives of all the tribes of Israel are ‘sealed’ (7:1-8).  This is a time of waiting and anticipation.  The heavenly silence of the seventh seal (8:1) may represent the ‘times of the gentiles’ (Lk. 21:24).

 

Both Revelation and the Gospels indicate there is a hiatus after the immediate post-Cross days (8:1; Lk. 21:24).  Then seven trumpets are prepared in heaven’s throne-room (8:2) before fire from the altar is added to the incense and prayers of God’s people in the golden censer (8:3-5a).  This study proposes that the eschaton, i.e. ‘last days’ or ‘end times’, begins when the censer is thrown to earth and there is another great storm and an earthquake (8:5b).  There are temptations for hedonism at this time (Lk. 21:34) and this may be represented in Revelation by Babylon’s corruption (17:1-18).  Then, the seven trumpets give warnings of impending judgement (from 8:6) and the bowls represent the outpouring of God’s judgement (from 15:1); the Parousia is imminent.

 

In conclusion, this study proposes that the torments of the seals and trumpets have been separated by at least two thousand years but events happen more quickly once the censer (in Revelation) is emptied.  The trumpets herald ‘the age to come’ and, from the fifth trumpet onwards, they warn of more intense torments when the three woes begin.  The third woe is the bowls, which represents the beginning of the Day of God’s Wrath.  Similarities and differences in the torments indicate they reflect cycles that affect succeeding eras (linearly), and there is no recapitulation (see Framework 2A and B).  After the (seventh) trumpet sounds, the Son of Man appears suddenly (Lk. 21:25-28, Mt. 24:29-31, Mk. 13:24-27).  No one knows when this may happen, and John is warned that Christ could appear at any time so the faithful must be aware, watchful and prepared (16:15).